When I was a kid, my parents used to say nothing good happens after midnight. Stay out too late, you find trouble.

If you run a trade business, the warning isn't about a time. It's about a tax form.

Nothing good happens after 1099.

Let's Be Honest With Each Other

I've been in the trades my whole life. Fourth generation. I run a contracting company. I know exactly why the 1099 model is tempting, because I've sat in the same chair you're sitting in and looked at the same bid sheet.

Comp premiums are brutal. Payroll tax adds up. Benefits cost real money. Unemployment insurance hits every paycheck. Overtime kills your margin when a job runs long. HR overhead is a tax on doing things right.

Call a guy a 1099 and all of that disappears. The labor line on your bid drops 25 to 30 percent overnight. You win more work. You make more money. The crew shows up, does the job, goes home, and you're not filing anything beyond a 1099 in January.

It looks like free money. It feels like free money. Everybody else in the industry is doing it, so it can't be that bad.

Let me tell you what it actually is: the most expensive labor you will ever buy. You just haven't gotten the bill yet.

The Question Worth Asking

"Is it illegal for me to 1099 an hourly worker?"

Short answer: yes, in almost every case where you're paying somebody by the hour to show up on your schedule and take direction from your foreman.

The Department of Labor is clear on this. What you call a worker doesn't matter. Whether the worker signed an independent contractor agreement doesn't matter. What matters is the economic reality of the relationship. If you control the schedule, the worksite, the tools, the materials, and the direction of the work, that worker is your employee — regardless of what your paperwork says.

The federal classification rules have been in flux. The 2024 Biden-era rule used a six-factor test. The current administration proposed a rollback in February 2026 to a simpler two-factor framework focused on control and opportunity for profit or loss. The comment period closed at the end of April.

But here's what every employer needs to understand: the pendulum swings. The tests change. The political winds shift. The fundamental question doesn't. If you're paying somebody by the hour to show up when you tell him to and do the work you direct, you have an employee. Every test — federal, state, IRS, ABC — arrives at the same answer.

State laws are getting tougher, not looser. The IRS coordinates with state task forces. Misclassification audits have intensified. The contractors who built their business on 1099 labor are running on borrowed time, and the smart ones already know it.

What It Actually Costs When You Get Caught

Back taxes to the IRS for every worker you misclassified, going back years. Back wages including unpaid overtime at time and a half for every hour over 40 those workers put in on your jobs. Federal fines that can run several thousand dollars per misclassified worker. Unpaid FICA. A charge per unfiled W-2. State unemployment taxes you should have been paying all along.

In states with real teeth on this — California, Massachusetts, New Jersey, and a growing list — the state penalties stack on top of the federal ones and are often worse. Some states have made misclassification a criminal offense for repeat offenders. Some states allow workers to sue for triple damages.

A single Department of Labor investigation, triggered by one disgruntled former worker, can cost a small contractor six figures by the time it's resolved. A class action from multiple workers — which is what usually happens once one person files — can put a small contractor out of business entirely.

And that's before we talk about the injury.

The Liability Shield You Don't Have

Workers' comp is not just a cost. It's a tradeoff. You pay the premium, the worker gets no-fault medical coverage and wage replacement if he gets hurt, and in exchange the worker gives up the right to sue you in civil court. That tradeoff is the entire reason comp exists. The premium isn't just buying coverage for the worker — it's buying a legal shield for you.

No comp policy on that worker. No tradeoff. No shield.

The 1099 guy you have framing your job slips off a roof and breaks his back. Without comp covering him, he can sue you directly for liability. There's no statutory cap on a personal injury verdict. His attorney is going to argue that you controlled the worksite, the safety protocols, and the direction of the work — and that same argument that proves he should have been classified as your employee is the argument that proves you're liable for his injury.

Your annual comp premium for that worker: a few thousand dollars. Your exposure without it: unlimited.

The 1099 game cuts both ways. The worker has no coverage. You have no protection. Everybody loses except the lawyer who takes the case.

What the Smart Contractors Are Doing

The contractors who are going to be standing in five years are the ones getting ahead of this right now. They're auditing their 1099 relationships. They're reclassifying the obvious cases. They're tightening up the arrangements that should genuinely be subcontractor work — which means real subcontractors with their own LLCs, their own insurance, their own crews, multiple clients, and the actual ability to profit or lose based on how they run the work.

They're rebuilding their bid models around legitimate labor costs, because they know the contractors competing against them on 1099 labor are about to get a very expensive education.

And they're using it as a competitive advantage. The best workers — the ones with real skills, real certifications, real experience — are increasingly looking past contractors who 1099 their crews. The good guys want a W-2. They want comp. They want overtime. They want a documented record of their career. They're choosing employers based on that, and they're telling their peers in the trade who treats them right and who doesn't.

The race to the bottom on labor cost is ending. The race to the top on labor quality is starting. You want to be on the right side of that shift.

What Collars Does For You

This is where Collars comes in.

The verified tradesmen on Collars are the ones who built their careers the right way. They have documented certifications, documented project history, documented skills, and a clean record of who they are and what they've done. They're exactly the workers you want on a W-2, because they're worth what you pay them — and they're also exactly the workers who won't stay long at a company that keeps calling them a 1099.

Collars helps you find the talent that will actually move your business forward. The tradesmen who take pride in their work, who have invested in their own development, who want a real career with a real employer who treats them like the professionals they are.

You don't beat the 1099 contractors by joining them. You beat them by hiring the workers they can't hold onto.

Nothing good happens after 1099. Everything good starts with treating the trades like the profession it has always been.

That's Collars.

‍